Meringue-Topped Key Lime Pie.
Often, I try something (lets just say a pie) and I think, oh man this is good, but could be a wee bit better if only it had that crust from such and such pie and maybe a bit of that sauce from the that other one. If I could just smash the three together, it would be perfect. This pie is one of those: favorite elements from different recipes, married together in perfect harmony.
The pie is made and baked in three distinct stages: the crust, the filling and the topping.
Graham Cracker Crust:
- 5 Tbsp melted butter
- 1 1/2 cups graham cracker crumbs
- 2-3 Tbsp sugar
- heavy pinch sea salt
Combine thoroughly and press with fingers into 9 to 9 1/2 inch pie pan. Careful to press crumbs evenly into the bottom and corners of the pan otherwise you will end up with an uneven crust. (I seem to always forget about the corners and end up with a sloped super thick crust corner that is hard to eat…watch out) Bake at 350 till lightly browned. Remove and cool on rack. Lower oven temp to 325.
Key Lime Filling:
- 2 cans of sweetened condensed milk (14 oz cans)
- 2 eggs
- 1 cup key lime juice - Nellie & Jo’s brand found here is the best-est of the rest-est (if you can’t find this or other “key lime” juice, just use regular lime juice, if jarred, use pure lime juice only - not already sweetened )
Whisk together ingredients and pour into pre-baked pie shell. Bake at 325 in middle of oven for about 15 minutes or until set in the middle (set=not still jiggling around like jello but not totally firm either). Chill in fridge for at least 2 hours. You can prepare up to this step the day before if you like.
Meringue Topping:
- 8 egg whites
- 2 cups sugar
- Stand mixer…is greatly appreciated
- Pot of water boiling on stove
- **
Preheat oven to 500. Mix egg whites and sugar together in bowl with whisk. Hold bowl (not letting water touch bottom of the bowl) over boiling water, whisking constantly. Whisk egg white/sugar mix over water till temp reaches about 100 degrees. What the? Don’t freak out - your body is 98.6, a hot hot tub is about 104 - shoot for the middle of that range (test with your finger, warmer than you, a wee bit less warm than a hot hot tub).
Transfer to stand mixer with whisk attachment. Beat on high till glossy and smooth. This may take a few minutes. Mixture will foam up and form medium peaks - see picture above, meringue holds a peak, but tips over. When it is mixing and it is oh so glossy and smooth and pretty and you just want to watch it go for a while - turn it off - NOW - and check. It is probably done. (What happens if you keep beating you ask? After too long it will start to dry out and create a crumbly texture.)
Spoon on top of pie. Use your wooden spoon or spatula to touch down on the meringue and “pull” up peaks. This par is so fun it is addictive. Your pie will have perfect peaks all over the place and you will still be getting them “right” for the thrill of watching them pull up just so.
Stick her back in the oven on 500 to brown. It’s scary, I know. It will be fine; better than fine. Check often. This is a 3-10 minute process depending on the strength of your oven and your desired brownness - just check every minute or so after the first three and remove when you have reached desired browning. The tops of the peaks should be crisp and golden, while the valleys are still white.
It is beautiful to look at, but better to eat.
**You will likely have plenty extra meringue. If you like, you can turn them into meringue cookies following the baking part of these instructions here (perhaps add vanilla or spice for extra flavor). They last forever and look adorable in glass jars on your kitchen shelves.